The Doughnut Revolution

Bridging Ideals and Reality: The Promise of Doughnut Economics

Hypothesis

"The Earth is what we all have in common." – Wendell Berry

This statement highlights humanity's shared responsibility to ensure the planet's sustainability. Sustainable growth is essential for meeting present needs without compromising future generations. In the face of climate change, inequality, and resource depletion, innovative frameworks like doughnut economics have gained attention. This analysis explores whether it can serve as a practical tool for sustainable growth or remains limited to theoretical discourse.

Null Hypothesis: Doughnut economics lacks practical applicability and fails to foster sustainable growth in real-world scenarios.

Alternate Hypothesis: The principles and framework of doughnut economics can be effectively applied to achieve sustainable growth by harmonizing social and ecological objectives.

Testing

In 2015, the United Nations adopted the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development—a blueprint to eradicate poverty, enhance human well-being, and protect the planet. However, as of 2024, progress remains alarmingly insufficient. The global poverty rate is projected to remain at 6.9% by 2030, with around 590 million people expected to live on less than $2.15 per day. This is a stark reminder of the widening gaps in socio-economic resilience, particularly in low-income and conflict-affected countries, where three-quarters of the world's extreme poor reside.

On the environmental front, we are perilously close to breaching the 1.5°C global warming threshold, with forecasts indicating a 66% probability of this happening between 2024 and 2027. Climate change is exacerbating poverty, trapping millions in cycles of vulnerability while undermining sustainable development efforts. Without transformative policies, these challenges will persist as a double burden for humanity and the planet​

The Doughnut in Doughnut Economics

The Doughnut Economics model, developed by Oxford economist Kate Raworth and introduced in her book Doughnut Economics: Seven Ways to Think Like a 21st-Century Economist, proposes a framework for a sustainable and equitable economy. It emphasizes the creation of a regenerative system that benefits both people and the planet while being practical to implement.

This model is visualized as a doughnut-shaped diagram split into three main areas:

1. Social Foundation:
   The inner boundary represents the basic human necessities, such as access to food, clean water, healthcare, education, energy, housing, social equity, and political representation. Meeting these needs is essential to ensure a just and equitable society.

2. Ecological Ceiling:
   The outer boundary defines the environmental limits within which humanity must operate to avoid ecological collapse. These limits include critical issues like climate change, biodiversity loss, freshwater depletion, air pollution, and ocean acidification.

3. Safe and Just Space for Humanity:
   The space between the social foundation and the ecological ceiling forms the "safe and just space" where both human well-being and planetary health can thrive in balance.

Any shortfall in meeting social foundations results in human suffering and inequality, while overshooting ecological boundaries causes environmental degradation. Achieving harmony between these boundaries is critical for fostering long-term sustainability and resilience.

How does the Economic Model work?

If humanity's aim in the 21st century is to ensure that everyone's basic needs are met within the planet's ecological boundaries—essentially thriving within the "Doughnut"—then traditional economic models are inadequate. Doughnut Economics offers a fresh perspective, not by prescribing rigid policies or institutions, but by fostering a mindset rooted in regeneration and equity. This approach is designed to address the unique challenges of our era by drawing on various economic schools of thought, including ecological, feminist, behavioral, institutional, and complexity economics.

The model emphasizes shifting the economic goal from unending GDP growth to achieving a balance where societies thrive within the Doughnut's safe and just space. This involves recognizing the interconnectedness of economies, societies, and the natural world. Doughnut Economics underscores that human behavior can evolve towards greater cooperation and care, counterbalancing the competitive and individualistic tendencies fostered by traditional economic paradigms.

Acknowledging that economies and ecosystems are intricately linked and operate as complex, interdependent systems, the framework promotes systems thinking as a way to understand and address these relationships. It calls for a transformation of today's extractive economies into regenerative ones that restore resources and ecosystems, and of divisive systems into distributive ones that ensure equity.

Finally, Doughnut Economics challenges the notion that growth should be perpetual. While growth may be a necessary phase in development, long-term success requires maturity—shifting focus from expansion to resilience and thriving. This perspective seeks to inspire economies to adapt and innovate in ways that prioritize sustainability and shared well-being.

What are the seven principles of the Model?

Having explored the concept of Doughnut Economics and its foundational areas, let’s delve into its seven principles, which outline a practical pathway to move from theory to actionable strategies. These principles serve as a guide for implementing the Doughnut framework in ways that align with both social equity and environmental sustainability.

1. Redefine the Goal: The first principle emphasizes reorienting the primary aim of economies away from endless GDP growth. Instead, the focus should shift toward achieving the balance represented by the Doughnut—ensuring the needs of all people are met while staying within planetary limits.

2. Adopt a Holistic Perspective: Economies, societies, and the environment are deeply interconnected. This principle urges a broader view, recognizing the economy not as an isolated entity but as one embedded within societal and ecological systems.

3. Support Human Flourishing: Central to the Doughnut’s framework is the acknowledgment of basic human needs and values. This principle underscores the importance of nurturing conditions that allow all individuals to thrive, placing humanity’s well-being at the forefront of economic objectives.

4. Engage with Systems Thinking: Understanding the complexities of interconnected systems is key to effective decision-making. This principle calls for a systems-based approach to identify solutions that align economic and environmental goals.

5. Promote Fairness in Design: Inequality is seen as a flaw in the system’s design. This principle advocates for creating structures that distribute resources and opportunities equitably, ensuring that value benefits all contributors and supports mutual prosperity.

6. Prioritize Regeneration: Moving beyond the extractive practices of the past, this principle focuses on regenerative design. It encourages reshaping economic activities to replenish ecosystems, promoting a circular model that restores rather than depletes.

7. Rethink Growth: The final principle challenges the traditional fixation on economic growth. Instead, it calls for a more nuanced approach that values sustainability, environmental health, and overall well-being over mere increases in monetary output.

These principles collectively guide a transition toward economies that are distributive and regenerative, aligning with the broader vision of creating a thriving, balanced world.

Case studies based on the Model

Sustainability models like Doughnut Economics provide frameworks for addressing pressing environmental and social challenges faced by countries, businesses, and communities. Below are examples of how this model has been applied in three cities worldwide:

1. Amsterdam, Netherlands

   Amsterdam became the first city to adopt the Doughnut Economics model to achieve full circularity in its raw material use by 2050. This strategy involves launching projects that stay within ecological limits while benefiting the city's environmental and economic goals.

   One notable initiative is the transformation of Fort Island Pampus, a UNESCO World Heritage site. The project includes transitioning its facilities—such as the entrance building and ports—to sustainable energy systems, eliminating reliance on fossil fuels. Beyond environmental benefits, the changes are expected to lower operational costs and enhance the island's contribution to Amsterdam’s social foundation, particularly in energy sustainability.

2. Melbourne, Australia

   The Regen Melbourne platform, established in 2020, aims to shift Greater Melbourne toward becoming a regenerative city in line with the Doughnut model. One flagship initiative focuses on restoring the Birrarung/Yarra River, aiming to make it swimmable by 2030.

   The project tackles pollution caused by deforestation and waste dumping, dividing efforts into areas like legal frameworks, river health, and public engagement in swimming activities. This effort aligns with the social foundations of access to water and health, while simultaneously reducing risks associated with biodiversity loss and freshwater withdrawal by rehabilitating the river and safeguarding the region's water resources.

3. Leeds, United Kingdom

   Climate Action Leeds adopted the Doughnut model to reimagine Leeds as a city where both people and the planet thrive. An in-depth analysis revealed that several dimensions of life in Leeds fall short of the social foundation while exceeding the ecological ceiling.

   To address these issues, the group aims to create a carbon-neutral, nature-friendly, and socially equitable city by 2030. Central to this vision is fostering community engagement. For this purpose, the Imagine Leeds initiative hosts monthly climate action events, bringing together residents, businesses, and stakeholders. These gatherings encourage collaborative, regenerative, and redistributive approaches to tackle the city's key sustainability challenges.

These examples demonstrate how Doughnut Economics can be adapted to diverse contexts, guiding cities toward achieving balanced and sustainable development.

Analyzing the Practicality of Doughnut Economics in context of India

The model envisions a "safe and just space" for humanity, where essential social needs are met without exceeding the planet’s ecological boundaries. While this concept is theoretically compelling, its practical application faces significant challenges, particularly in a diverse and developing country like India, where addressing developmental disparities often takes precedence over environmental concerns. The interplay between social equity and ecological sustainability is intricate, making the implementation of Doughnut Economics a complex endeavor.

In the Indian context, gaps in the social foundation are both stark and persistent. Millions of people continue to live in poverty, with over 35% of children under the age of five suffering from stunting due to malnutrition. Access to essential services such as healthcare, education, and sanitation remains uneven, particularly in rural areas and marginalized communities. Addressing these issues requires substantial investment in infrastructure, resources, and social programs. However, such interventions often come at the cost of increased environmental pressure, as they typically involve resource extraction, energy consumption, and urban expansion. Balancing these developmental imperatives with ecological limits is a central challenge for India in the context of Doughnut Economics.

At the same time, India grapples with severe ecological challenges that underscore the urgency of sustainability. The country ranks among the world's most polluted, with air quality in cities like Delhi frequently reaching hazardous levels. Water resources are under immense stress, with several major cities facing the prospect of water scarcity in the coming decades. India’s reliance on coal for energy and rapid industrialization make it the third-largest emitter of CO₂ globally, further straining its ecological capacity. While the government has introduced initiatives such as the National Solar Mission and efforts to promote electric vehicles, these policies lack a cohesive strategy that integrates them into a broader framework for sustainable development. This fragmented approach highlights the difficulty of reconciling India's growth ambitions with its ecological responsibilities.

One of the core challenges in applying Doughnut Economics to India is the nation’s growth-centric development model. Economic growth is seen as essential for creating jobs and lifting millions out of poverty. However, this focus on GDP often conflicts with the principles of Doughnut Economics, which advocate for a shift away from growth as the primary measure of progress. Transitioning to a model that prioritizes social equity and ecological sustainability requires a fundamental restructuring of policies and economic systems, which may be perceived as slowing down development in the short term. For a country like India, where immediate developmental needs are pressing, such a shift can seem politically and economically unviable.

Nevertheless, Doughnut Economics provides valuable insights that could guide reforms in India. A localized approach, tailoring the model to specific states or cities, could make it more actionable. For instance, urban centers like Bengaluru and Mumbai, which face acute environmental challenges, could adopt localized "doughnut" models to address their unique social and ecological contexts. Integrating sustainability into development policies, such as promoting green energy, adopting sustainable agricultural practices, and encouraging circular economy principles, can also align with Doughnut Economics’ goals. Additionally, participatory governance, which involves communities in decision-making, can ensure that solutions are equitable and context-sensitive.

Conclusion

Based on the analysis, we reject the null hypothesis that Doughnut Economics lacks practical applicability and fails to foster sustainable growth in real-world scenarios. While it may not yet function as a standalone policy framework, the principles and framework of Doughnut Economics demonstrate substantial potential for shaping sustainable growth, particularly in a diverse and resource-constrained context like India. By harmonizing social and ecological objectives, Doughnut Economics provides a valuable guide for embedding sustainability into existing development paradigms. India, with its pressing developmental and environmental challenges, could leverage these principles to build a future where human well-being is achieved without exceeding planetary boundaries. This hybrid approach, though complex, is not only feasible but also essential for fostering a resilient and inclusive society amidst increasing ecological and social pressures.

---

We’ll meet you soon while you enjoy your doughnuts this Christmas season. Till then, we can correspond earlier if you have feedback or a topic you want us to cover. Feel free to use the comment section or write to us at economally@gmail.com.

Thank you for reading and see you soon!